PiedWatch

537 Atlantic Avenue, Brooklyn 11217

This property may be subject to NYC’s non-primary residence (pied-à-terre) surcharge.

Photo of 537 Atlantic Avenue
© Mapillary contributors
Market value (FY27)
$5,354,000
Estimated annual surcharge
If non-primary, est. $42,832/yr · 0.8% tier (Class 1, $5M–$15M)
Owner of record
Atlantic Gardens Llc
Borough
Brooklyn
Block / Lot
180 / 54
BBL (PARID)
3001800054
Tax class
1
Building class
S2

Estimate = phase-1 rate × FY27 DOF market value. Co-op unit values are imputed by DOF at determination; see methodology.

Ownership records

Last deed recorded December 18, 2024 for $25,000,000. Thor Atlantic Gardens LLC → Atlantic Gardens LLC

  • Seller Thor Atlantic Gardens LLC
    25 West 39th Street, New York, NY 10018
  • Buyer Atlantic Gardens LLC
    131 Spring Street, New York, NY 10012

City housing registration (HPD)

  • Agent GEN.PART Jair Gutierrez
    131 Spring Street Suite, New York, NY 10012
  • Corporate Owner GEN.PART Atlantic Gardens LLC
    131 Spring Street Suite, New York, NY 10012
  • Head Officer GEN.PART Marla Siegel
    131 Spring Street Suite, New York, NY 10012
  • Site Manager GEN.PART Jair Gutierrez

Public ACRIS deed records and HPD registration data. LLC officers are not published by New York State; parties and addresses shown are as recorded.

Historic photos

  • 1940s tax photo of 537 Atlantic Avenue, NYC

    1939–41 tax photo · © City of New York, NYC Municipal Archives · via 1940s.nyc

  • 1980s tax photo of 537 Atlantic Avenue, NYC

    1980s tax photo · © City of New York, NYC Municipal Archives · via 1940s.nyc

NYC Municipal Archives tax photographs — view on 1940s.nyc (opens in new tab). Images © City of New York; bulk/commercial reuse requires Archives permission.

View deeds & mortgages in ACRIS